With the league offices closing for today, the second Tuesday after the 2017 NFL Draft, it also closes out the addition of compensatory free agents (CFAs) into the formula for the 2018 NFL Draft. With only CFA subtractions now possible due to cuts or too low of a salary, it’s time to take a look at the list that’s emerged.
There is a bit of the changing of the guard in the teams seen in this year’s list. A few stalwarts like New England, Baltimore and Cincinnati remain prominent, but others like Green Bay, Denver, Seattle, and Pittsburgh are starkly missing. In their place are some teams with notable circumstances within 2018 free agency: the Los Angeles Rams (who like New England are on track to get two 3rd round comp picks), Minnesota (who saw three quarterbacks leave in free agency), Philadelphia (a major sleeper on pursuing comp picks, as I’ll explain below) and Washington (who, despite their hard earned reputation of being big time UFA spenders, are poised to break the longest active regular comp pick drought. The last time they got one was 2009, a 7th rounder that was used to draft Marko Mitchell.)
Also notable is that this could be the first year under the current CBA that getting a seven figure APY is required to qualify for the compensatory formula. Currently, Geno Smith, at $1 million even, is on the bubble of qualifying, and with him out of consideration (as is likely unless something disastrous happens to the durable Philip Rivers) it opens up a 7th rounder to the Chargers for either Kenny Wiggins or Matt Slauson, and also takes off the board a 4th rounder to the Giants for either Weston Richburg or Justin Pugh.
There are two players that, despite being listed as Unrestricted Free Agents in the official press release, I am guessing will not qualify for the compensatory formula. They are Donald Stephenson, going from Denver to Cleveland, and Derrick Johnson, going from Kansas City to Oakland. This is because both Stephenson and Johnson had their contracts shortened by renegotiating voids in their 2018 year in exchange for taking pay pay cuts in 2017. This is unfortunate for both the Broncos and Chiefs, as it will negatively impact their comp pick ledgers. For Denver, if Stephenson counted it would open up a 7th rounder for Corey Nelson (although he would be unlikely to make the 32-pick limit). Otherwise, it will end the Broncos’ four year streak of obtaining or being eligible compensatory picks–unless Brock Osweiler somehow becomes the Dolphins’ starting quarterback for most to all of 2018. The Chiefs, however, are projected to get a 6th or 7th rounder for Terrence Mitchell as of now, but if Johnson qualified they would likely get another 6th or 7th rounder for him as well.
The other unusual case involves Mike Wallace, going from Baltimore to Philadelphia. As I mentioned above, the Eagles are a team that have been largely ignored in recent comp pick studies, but historically this is mistaken to do so. From 2004 to 2011, the Eagles got multiple comp picks in six of those eight drafts, and were second only to Baltimore in the most total comp picks awarded. Howie Roseman was a high level executive with the team during those times, and looking at how he’s crafted some of his CFA signings, there are signs that he just as determined as Ozzie Newsome, Bill Belichick, or John Elway in manipulating the comp pick system.
This brings us back to Wallace. Early reports had his Eagles’ deal as one year and “up to” $4 million. However, it was soon discovered that there was plenty of funny money in that deal. $2.085 million of that $4 million are in Likely To Be Earned incentives, and among the most laughable was a $585,000 weight bonus to be earned by reporting to offseason workouts under 250 pounds. It’s laughable because Wallace, a wide receiver, has consistently played at a relatively svelte 200 pounds. But the comp pick formula shines insight on this unusual bonus, as it’s established that weight bonuses do not count. (See Terrance Knighton demoting a comp pick for Denver in 2016.)
But it doesn’t end there. Wallace’s $1 million signing bonus is actually an OATSB–Other Amount Treated As Signing Bonus. OTC also believes that this OATSB is a guaranteed workout bonus. Although it’s unclear how the comp pick formula will judge such a payment, it has been very consistent in not counting workout bonuses of any kind. Because there are many signs suggesting that the Eagles are manipulating the formula with Wallace’s contract, I’m therefore guessing that this $1 million will not count either. If that guess is correct, all that’s left to count is Wallace’s veteran minimum base salary of $915,000, and while he could still qualify if he plays enough snaps, currently that’s not enough to break the current qualification limit of $1 million.
The end result? If Wallace does not qualify, as I have it so right now, it opens up an additional 6th rounder to Philadelphia for Patrick Robinson, and it potentially costs Baltimore a 7th for Wallace.
Team | Round | Compensated Free Agent | APY |
---|---|---|---|
WAS | 3 | Kirk Cousins | $28,000,000 |
MIN | 3 | Case Keenum | $18,000,000 |
LAR | 3 | Sammy Watkins | $15,830,000 |
NE | 3 | Nate Solder | $15,400,000 |
LAR | 3 | Trumaine Johnson | $14,500,000 |
CAR | 3 | Andrew Norwell | $13,000,000 |
NE | 3 | Malcolm Butler | $12,170,000 |
BAL | 4 | Ryan Jensen | $10,500,000 |
IND | 4 | Donte Moncrief | $9,600,000 |
DAL | 4 | Anthony Hitchens | $8,838,000 |
ATL | 4 | Dontari Poe | $8,533,333 |
PHI | 4 | Trey Burton | $7,925,000 |
WAS | 5 | Spencer Long | $6,850,000 |
ATL | 5 | Taylor Gabriel | $6,500,000 |
DET | 5 | D.J. Hayden | $6,333,333 |
MIN | 6 | Teddy Bridgewater | $5,500,000 |
WAS | 6 | Ryan Grant | $5,000,000 |
PHI | 6 | Beau Allen | $5,000,000 |
NE | 6 | Dion Lewis | $4,950,000 |
PHI | 6 | Patrick Robinson | $4,925,000 |
WAS | 6 | Terrelle Pryor | $4,500,000 |
CIN | 6 | Andre Smith | $4,000,000 |
CIN | 6 | AJ McCarron | $3,950,000 |
CIN | 6 | Chris Smith | $3,900,000 |
CAR | 6 | Ed Dickson | $3,566,667 |
KC | 6 | Terrance Mitchell | $3,233,333 |
MIN | 7 | Tramaine Brock | $3,000,000 |
ARI | 7 | Jaron Brown | $2,750,000 |
NE | 7 | Cameron Fleming | $2,500,000 |
LAC | 7 | Kenny Wiggins | $2,500,000 |
LAR | 7 | Cody Davis | $2,500,000 |
MIN | 7 | Shamar Stephen | $2,100,000 |
Compensation over 32-pick limit; not awarded | |||
ARI | 7 | Blaine Gabbert | $2,000,000 |
ARI | 7 | Matt Barkley | $1,400,000 |
LAR | 7 | Derek Carrier | $1,275,000 |
ARI | 7 | Earl Watford | $1,250,000 |
SF | 7 | Tank Carradine | $1,150,000 |
IND | 7 | Frank Gore | $1,105,000 |
SF | 7 | Leon Hall | $1,060,000 |
SF | 7 | Logan Paulsen | $1,005,000 |
For the next few months, the most important thing to watch for with regard to 2019 compensatory picks is if any CFAs fail to make and stay on their team’s roster. If any CFA is permanently cut from their team’s roster before Week 10, they will not qualify for the compensatory formula. Using a little intuition, there are some teams that could feasibly improve their standing in 2018 compensatory picks if they cut certain players, and other teams that need to hope that certain teams don’t cut some of their former players.
With the 2024 NFL Draft in the books we now have a final estimate for…
With the second round of the 2024 draft in the books I wanted to go…
With the first round of the 2024 draft in the books I wanted to go…
For those who are premium subscribers I put together a pdf file breaking down the…
With only a few days before the 2024 NFL Draft, it's that time again to…
Every year as the draft approaches I like to look at different trends over the…