| Adam Vinatieri | 1996‑2019 | $51,132,000 | $128,026,658 | Colts: $39,700,000 Patriots: $11,432,000 |
| Justin Tucker | 2012‑ | $51,046,000 | $77,013,662 | Ravens: $51,046,000 |
| Sebastian Janikowski | 2000‑2018 | $48,770,500 | $119,875,871 | Raiders: $46,755,500 Seahawks: $2,015,000 |
| Graham Gano | 2014‑ | $46,635,000 | $70,805,549 | Giants: $23,835,000 Panthers: $22,800,000 |
| Stephen Gostkowski | 2006‑2020 | $43,495,875 | $83,263,114 | Patriots: $40,761,500 Titans: $2,734,375 |
| Phil Dawson | 1998‑2018 | $35,705,000 | $82,485,810 | Browns: $18,029,000 49ers: $11,518,000 Cardinals: $6,000,000 Patriots: $158,000 |
| Brandon McManus | 2016‑ | $35,703,138 | $49,253,089 | Broncos: $24,396,471 Packers: $7,806,667 Jaguars: $2,000,000 Commanders: $1,500,000 |
| Chris Boswell | 2015‑ | $34,961,947 | $49,411,578 | Steelers: $34,952,647 Texans: $9,300 |
| Matt Prater | 2015‑2024 | $34,650,000 | $51,992,890 | Lions: $20,400,000 Cardinals: $14,250,000 |
| Ryan Succop | 2009‑2022 | $32,800,250 | $57,624,152 | Titans: $16,195,000 Buccaneers: $9,300,000 Chiefs: $7,305,250 |
| Matt Bryant | 2002‑2018 | $31,350,736 | $65,904,610 | Falcons: $25,736,618 Buccaneers: $4,955,000 Giants: $525,000 Dolphins: $111,765 Colts: $22,353 |
| Jason Myers | 2015‑ | $29,632,059 | $40,312,078 | Seahawks: $27,750,000 Jaguars: $1,177,059 Jets: $705,000 |
| Mason Crosby | 2016‑2023 | $29,258,888 | $45,318,307 | Packers: $29,000,000 Giants: $194,166 Rams: $64,722 |
| Ka'imi Fairbairn | 2016‑ | $28,605,500 | $38,394,055 | Texans: $28,605,500 |
| Harrison Butker | 2017‑ | $26,399,442 | $34,664,904 | Chiefs: $26,254,412 Panthers: $145,030 |
| Greg Zuerlein | 2012‑ | $25,757,826 | $38,115,413 | Rams: $11,275,473 Jets: $9,482,353 Cowboys: $5,000,000 |
| Dustin Hopkins | 2013‑ | $25,360,797 | $35,337,799 | Commanders: $12,357,500 Browns: $8,367,941 Chargers: $4,176,944 Bills: $434,412 Saints: $24,000 |
| Jake Elliott | 2017‑ | $25,142,055 | $32,965,037 | Eagles: $24,857,647 Bengals: $284,408 |
| Wil Lutz | 2016‑ | $24,882,500 | $34,337,343 | Saints: $18,670,000 Broncos: $6,210,000 Ravens: $2,500 |
| Robbie Gould | 2017‑2022 | $22,250,000 | $32,721,061 | 49ers: $21,750,000 Bears: $500,000 |
| Jason Elam | 1993‑2009 | $21,050,902 | $75,833,866 | Broncos: $16,020,902 Falcons: $5,030,000 |
| Cairo Santos | 2017‑ | $19,765,324 | $26,576,846 | Bears: $16,903,529 Chiefs: $951,353 Titans: $805,000 Jets: $500,000 Buccaneers: $454,412 Rams: $151,030 |
| Daniel Carlson | 2018‑ | $19,340,837 | $26,175,453 | Raiders: $19,036,354 Vikings: $304,483 |
| Dan Bailey | 2014‑2020 | $19,300,000 | $33,672,072 | Cowboys: $12,300,000 Vikings: $7,000,000 |
| Jason Hanson | 1992‑2012 | $18,822,500 | $75,361,485 | Lions: $18,822,500 |
| Matt Gay | 2019‑2024 | $17,631,513 | $22,079,486 | Colts: $13,142,800 Rams: $3,667,941 Buccaneers: $820,772 |
| Younghoe Koo | 2019‑ | $17,625,530 | $22,613,589 | Falcons: $17,471,765 Chargers: $137,765 Patriots: $16,000 |
| Mike Nugent | 2005‑2020 | $17,524,184 | $39,097,699 | Bengals: $10,094,478 Jets: $3,160,000 Buccaneers: $2,400,000 Raiders: $597,471 Cardinals: $500,471 Cowboys: $294,117 Patriots: $242,353 Bears: $235,294 |
| Jason Sanders | 2018‑ | $16,561,200 | $22,105,868 | Dolphins: $16,561,200 |
| Nick Folk | 2017‑2024 | $14,831,846 | $20,002,071 | Patriots: $7,171,846 Titans: $5,910,000 Buccaneers: $1,750,000 |
| Josh Lambo | 2015‑2020 | $13,440,663 | $20,372,549 | Jaguars: $12,399,441 Chargers: $965,000 Titans: $62,222 Steelers: $14,000 |
| Randy Bullock | 2012‑2023 | $13,346,203 | $21,096,027 | Bengals: $5,889,118 Titans: $3,552,219 Texans: $1,587,106 Giants: $1,228,055 Lions: $750,000 Jets: $275,294 Steelers: $64,411 |
| Stephen Hauschka | 2017‑2019 | $12,470,882 | $19,529,252 | Bills: $12,125,000 Jaguars: $345,882 |
| Tyler Bass | 2020‑ | $11,979,224 | $14,817,723 | Bills: $11,979,224 |
| Cody Parkey | 2016‑2020 | $11,961,461 | $18,514,884 | Bears: $9,000,000 Browns: $1,714,550 Dolphins: $690,000 Saints: $367,499 Titans: $189,412 |
| Evan McPherson | 2021‑ | $8,823,716 | $10,428,610 | Bengals: $8,823,716 |
| Zane Gonzalez | 2017‑ | $8,748,708 | $12,307,951 | Cardinals: $4,074,835 Panthers: $3,270,000 Browns: $619,462 Commanders: $526,244 49ers: $244,167 Lions: $14,000 |
| Chase McLaughlin | 2019‑ | $8,643,047 | $10,477,632 | Buccaneers: $6,130,000 Colts: $1,027,860 Browns: $850,000 Jaguars: $198,529 Jets: $119,118 Chargers: $116,470 49ers: $116,470 Vikings: $83,600 Bills: $1,000 |
| Shaun Suisham | 2014‑2015 | $8,450,000 | $16,706,225 | Steelers: $8,450,000 |
| Blair Walsh | 2012‑2020 | $8,296,057 | $16,102,913 | Vikings: $7,196,057 Seahawks: $1,100,000 |
| Eddy Pineiro | 2018‑2024 | $7,528,667 | $9,651,761 | Panthers: $4,995,000 Bears: $1,170,000 Jets: $916,667 Raiders: $388,000 Colts: $45,000 Commanders: $14,000 |
| Joey Slye | 2019‑ | $7,332,167 | $9,558,457 | Commanders: $4,560,834 Patriots: $1,267,500 Panthers: $1,170,000 49ers: $188,889 Texans: $94,444 Jaguars: $25,000 Titans: $25,000 Giants: $500 |
| Dan Carpenter | 2014‑2016 | $7,325,000 | $14,489,150 | Bills: $7,300,000 Dolphins: $25,000 |
| Chandler Catanzaro | 2014‑2019 | $6,867,382 | $11,405,422 | Buccaneers: $3,750,000 Cardinals: $1,531,500 Jets: $1,400,000 Panthers: $185,882 |
| Greg Joseph | 2018‑2024 | $6,574,928 | $8,726,028 | Vikings: $5,213,000 Giants: $438,334 Browns: $423,529 Buccaneers: $174,106 Jets: $79,300 Commanders: $79,300 Titans: $67,059 Packers: $50,000 Panthers: $24,000 Lions: $21,300 Dolphins: $5,000 |
| Caleb Sturgis | 2013‑2017 | $5,501,325 | $9,739,720 | Chargers: $2,250,000 Eagles: $2,206,765 Dolphins: $1,044,560 |
| Cameron Dicker | 2022‑ | $5,332,335 | $6,077,000 | Chargers: $5,246,668 Eagles: $73,667 Rams: $12,000 |
| Michael Badgley | 2018‑2024 | $5,278,265 | $7,019,873 | Lions: $2,870,800 Chargers: $1,638,188 Colts: $668,444 Titans: $51,111 Bears: $49,722 |
| Josh Brown | 2014‑2015 | $4,256,066 | $8,217,534 | Giants: $4,256,066 |
| Garrett Hartley | 9999‑0 | $3,937,482 | $8,683,107 | Saints: $3,681,600 Steelers: $255,882 |
| Austin Seibert | 2019‑2024 | $3,626,034 | $4,939,147 | Lions: $1,118,056 Commanders: $877,500 Browns: $795,162 Bengals: $635,294 Jets: $165,022 Saints: $35,000 |
| Rob Bironas | 2013‑2013 | $3,550,000 | $8,058,211 | Titans: $3,550,000 |
| Josh Scobee | 9999‑0 | $3,450,000 | $6,722,781 | Steelers: $2,500,000 Jaguars: $950,000 |
| Brett Maher | 2018‑2023 | $3,001,857 | $4,241,992 | Cowboys: $1,914,412 Rams: $480,000 Saints: $429,445 Texans: $75,600 Broncos: $52,000 Commanders: $33,600 Cardinals: $16,800 |
| Aldrick Rosas | 2017‑2021 | $2,812,226 | $4,282,598 | Giants: $1,665,000 Jaguars: $410,776 Saints: $382,250 Lions: $353,200 Titans: $1,000 |
| Jake Moody | 2023‑ | $2,598,607 | $3,079,971 | 49ers: $2,598,607 |
| Blake Gillikin | 2024‑ | $2,500,000 | $2,822,251 | Cardinals: $1,900,000 Saints: $600,000 |
| Riley Patterson | 2021‑2024 | $2,481,243 | $3,205,442 | Lions: $1,076,666 Jaguars: $825,000 Falcons: $234,444 Browns: $163,055 Jets: $117,222 Patriots: $36,800 Vikings: $28,056 |
| Alex Henery | 2011‑2014 | $2,422,166 | $5,454,876 | Eagles: $1,815,108 Lions: $607,058 |
| Kai Forbath | 2016‑2019 | $2,306,795 | $3,719,658 | Vikings: $1,237,941 Rams: $361,765 Cowboys: $301,618 Saints: $170,706 Jaguars: $139,412 Patriots: $47,353 Panthers: $24,000 Bears: $24,000 |
| Chad Ryland | 2023‑ | $2,248,414 | $2,686,614 | Patriots: $1,536,748 Cardinals: $711,666 |
| Cade York | 2022‑2024 | $2,136,306 | $2,746,485 | Browns: $1,434,640 Giants: $277,333 Bengals: $273,611 Titans: $96,000 Commanders: $54,722 |
| Roberto Aguayo | 2016‑2020 | $2,042,120 | $3,611,454 | Buccaneers: $1,597,320 Bears: $377,600 Panthers: $50,400 Patriots: $16,800 |
| Sam Ficken | 2017‑2022 | $1,866,558 | $2,734,311 | Jets: $1,140,882 Titans: $465,000 Lions: $149,500 Rams: $111,176 |
| Nick Novak | 2016‑2017 | $1,756,176 | $3,057,955 | Texans: $1,215,000 Chargers: $541,176 |
| Matthew Wright | 2020‑ | $1,675,223 | $2,234,541 | Jaguars: $563,333 Steelers: $378,057 Chiefs: $332,778 49ers: $191,722 Titans: $117,222 Panthers: $56,111 Patriots: $24,000 Falcons: $12,000 |
| Daniel Whelan | 2023‑ | $1,675,000 | $1,945,171 | Packers: $1,665,000 Saints: $10,000 |
| Blake Grupe | 2023‑ | $1,667,500 | $1,934,866 | Saints: $1,667,500 |
| Brandon Aubrey | 2023‑ | $1,665,000 | $1,931,761 | Cowboys: $1,665,000 |
| Anders Carlson | 2023‑ | $1,389,275 | $1,653,671 | Packers: $906,776 Jets: $368,333 49ers: $114,166 |
| Rodrigo Blankenship | 2020‑2021 | $1,363,332 | $1,971,806 | Colts: $1,214,166 Cardinals: $149,166 |
| Billy Cundiff | 9999‑0 | $1,205,441 | $2,502,589 | Browns: $1,020,000 Bills: $185,441 |
| Rian Lindell | 2013‑2013 | $1,005,000 | $2,281,268 | Buccaneers: $1,005,000 |
| David Akers | 2013‑2013 | $1,005,000 | $2,281,268 | Lions: $1,005,000 |
| Connor Barth | 9999‑0 | $980,000 | $1,638,419 | Bears: $980,000 |
| Matt Ammendola | 2021‑2022 | $978,610 | $1,385,180 | Jets: $522,667 Texans: $261,110 Chiefs: $91,667 Cardinals: $91,666 Packers: $11,500 |
| Andrew Franks | 2015‑2016 | $960,000 | $1,791,688 | Dolphins: $960,000 |
| Jake Bates | 2024‑ | $945,000 | $1,033,062 | Lions: $945,000 |
| Cam Little | 2024‑ | $933,388 | $1,020,368 | Jaguars: $933,388 |
| Joshua Karty | 2024‑ | $933,388 | $1,020,368 | Rams: $933,388 |
| Giorgio Tavecchio | 2017‑2018 | $920,918 | $1,504,450 | Raiders: $545,000 Falcons: $359,118 Titans: $16,800 |
| Lawrence Tynes | 2013‑2013 | $905,000 | $2,054,276 | Buccaneers: $905,000 |
| Will Reichard | 2024‑ | $893,398 | $976,651 | Vikings: $893,398 |
| Taylor Bertolet | 2020‑2022 | $796,766 | $429,904 | Jets: $480,000 Chargers: $229,666 Panthers: $61,900 Vikings: $25,200 |
| Spencer Shrader | 2024‑ | $771,389 | $815,316 | Colts: $451,667 Chiefs: $263,055 Jets: $56,667 |
| Patrick Murray | 2016‑2017 | $729,530 | $1,263,667 | Buccaneers: $381,176 Browns: $348,354 |
| Tristan Vizcaino | 2020‑2022 | $687,316 | $999,173 | Chargers: $385,333 Patriots: $193,334 Cardinals: $39,167 49ers: $35,882 Vikings: $33,600 |
| Lucas Havrisik | 9999‑0 | $549,666 | $678,240 | Rams: $416,666 Browns: $84,000 Bills: $37,500 Colts: $11,500 |
| Ryan Santoso | 9999‑0 | $544,597 | $810,269 | Lions: $196,999 Giants: $170,912 Titans: $96,553 Panthers: $43,333 Rams: $36,800 |
| John Potter | 2012‑2012 | $520,601 | $1,201,412 | Bills: $435,896 Commanders: $84,705 |
| Brian Johnson | 2021‑2021 | $495,200 | $757,588 | Saints: $220,000 Commanders: $220,000 Bears: $55,200 |
| Sam Sloman | 2020‑2021 | $462,050 | $655,676 | Rams: $326,668 Titans: $77,882 Steelers: $46,000 49ers: $11,500 |
| Justin Rohrwasser | 2020‑2020 | $458,196 | $645,451 | Patriots: $458,196 |
| Caleb Shudak | 2022‑2022 | $408,611 | $547,955 | Titans: $408,611 |
| Brayden Narveson | 9999‑0 | $383,334 | $419,056 | Packers: $309,167 Titans: $74,167 |
| Matt McCrane | 2018‑2021 | $378,811 | $556,053 | Browns: $126,000 Raiders: $112,941 Cardinals: $46,535 Lions: $37,500 Steelers: $28,235 Eagles: $27,600 |
| Quinn Nordin | 2021‑2022 | $372,946 | $570,556 | Patriots: $372,946 |
| Dominik Eberle | 2020‑2021 | $355,134 | $510,878 | Raiders: $152,800 Lions: $73,667 Panthers: $73,600 Texans: $55,067 |
| John Parker Romo | 2024‑ | $343,333 | $384,875 | Vikings: $230,833 Bears: $60,000 Patriots: $50,000 Saints: $2,500 |
| Elliott Fry | 2020‑2021 | $337,227 | $488,519 | Falcons: $218,682 Jaguars: $47,778 Chiefs: $45,867 Bengals: $9,200 Packers: $9,200 Panthers: $6,500 |
| Sergio Castillo | 2020‑2020 | $320,659 | $451,705 | Jets: $320,659 |
| Nick Rose | 2017‑2017 | $301,882 | $504,830 | Commanders: $246,176 Chargers: $54,706 Falcons: $1,000 |
| Zach Hocker | 9999‑0 | $290,541 | $575,232 | Saints: $153,529 Rams: $76,764 Commanders: $60,248 |
| Tucker McCann | 2020‑2020 | $286,133 | $406,559 | Titans: $286,133 |
| Ramiz Ahmed | 2022‑2022 | $262,334 | $351,795 | Packers: $262,334 |
| James McCourt | 2022‑2022 | $253,667 | $336,046 | Jaguars: $207,000 Raiders: $41,667 Chargers: $5,000 |
| Chris Naggar | 9999‑0 | $220,334 | $337,081 | Browns: $211,334 Jets: $9,000 |
| Austin MacGinnis | 2020‑2020 | $195,482 | $275,371 | Rams: $195,482 |
| Lirim Hajrullahu | 2021‑2021 | $191,867 | $292,512 | Panthers: $118,400 Cowboys: $55,067 Commanders: $18,400 |
| J.J. Molson | 2020‑2021 | $190,800 | $288,844 | Packers: $182,400 Chargers: $8,400 |
| Jose Borregales | 2021‑2021 | $168,100 | $257,170 | Buccaneers: $168,100 |
| Jake Verity | 2021‑2021 | $165,600 | $253,345 | Ravens: $165,600 |
| Brandon Wright | 2020‑2020 | $159,294 | $222,394 | Jaguars: $122,094 Rams: $37,200 |
| Chris Blewitt | 2021‑2021 | $146,800 | $224,584 | Commanders: $128,400 Browns: $18,400 |
| Nate Freese | 9999‑0 | $132,542 | $278,239 | Lions: $132,542 |
| Jon Brown | 2017‑2017 | $129,365 | $184,129 | Jaguars: $122,165 Bengals: $7,200 |
| Kyle Brindza | 9999‑0 | $109,853 | $214,063 | Buccaneers: $102,353 Lions: $7,500 |
| Travis Coons | 9999‑0 | $100,295 | $169,816 | Chargers: $95,295 Titans: $5,000 |
| Shayne Graham | 9999‑0 | $72,647 | $159,983 | Steelers: $32,647 Browns: $20,000 Saints: $20,000 |
| Marshall Koehn | 9999‑0 | $72,405 | $119,904 | Bengals: $54,705 Giants: $15,200 Dolphins: $2,500 |
| Gabe Brkic | 9999‑0 | $71,667 | $96,107 | Packers: $71,667 |
| Alex Kessman | 9999‑0 | $65,067 | $99,544 | Jets: $45,867 Chargers: $10,000 Panthers: $9,200 |
| Kaare Vedvik | 9999‑0 | $64,129 | $93,962 | Jets: $33,529 Bills: $13,000 Jaguars: $9,200 Panthers: $8,400 |
| Taylor Russolino | 2020‑2020 | $61,082 | $86,045 | Broncos: $61,082 |
| Andrew Mevis | 9999‑0 | $60,000 | $80,461 | Jaguars: $60,000 |
| Jonathan Garibay | 9999‑0 | $55,000 | $73,756 | Cowboys: $55,000 |
| Tanner Brown | 9999‑0 | $53,000 | $58,385 | Rams: $28,000 Falcons: $25,000 |
| Nick Sciba | 9999‑0 | $50,667 | $67,945 | Steelers: $50,667 |
| Jude McAtamney | 2024‑ | $41,667 | $45,550 | Giants: $41,667 |
| Marshall Morgan | 9999‑0 | $32,600 | $58,620 | Bills: $32,600 |
| Mike Meyer | 9999‑0 | $22,600 | $38,061 | Falcons: $14,400 Jaguars: $7,200 Titans: $1,000 |
| Ty Long | 9999‑0 | $15,400 | $20,652 | Jets: $15,400 |
| John Baron | 9999‑0 | $15,000 | $22,253 | Bears: $15,000 |
| Jack Podlesny | 9999‑0 | $15,000 | $18,630 | Vikings: $15,000 |
| Andre Szmyt | 2025‑ | $14,500 | $16,149 | Browns: $12,500 Bears: $2,000 |
| Blake Haubeil | 9999‑0 | $14,200 | $21,724 | Panthers: $9,200 Titans: $5,000 |
| Lenny Krieg | 2025‑ | $10,000 | $10,000 | Falcons: $10,000 |
| John Lunsford | 9999‑0 | $10,000 | $17,982 | 49ers: $10,000 |
| Josh Gable | 9999‑0 | $8,000 | $11,868 | Patriots: $8,000 |
| Carey Spear | 9999‑0 | $5,000 | $10,496 | Eagles: $5,000 |
| B.T. Potter | 9999‑0 | $5,000 | $6,210 | Steelers: $5,000 |
| Ross Martin | 9999‑0 | $5,000 | $8,991 | Jets: $5,000 |
| Derek Dimke | 9999‑0 | $5,000 | $10,496 | Saints: $5,000 |
| Trevor Moore | 9999‑0 | $4,000 | $6,302 | Buccaneers: $4,000 |
| Trey Wolff | 9999‑0 | $3,500 | $4,347 | Titans: $3,500 |
| Christopher Dunn | 9999‑0 | $3,000 | $3,726 | Rams: $3,000 |
| Harrison Mevis | 9999‑0 | $3,000 | $3,280 | Panthers: $3,000 |
| Quinn Sharp | 9999‑0 | $2,500 | $5,675 | Bengals: $2,500 |
| Tom Obarski | 9999‑0 | $2,500 | $4,872 | Bengals: $2,500 |
| Tyler Davis | 9999‑0 | $2,500 | $3,939 | Bills: $2,500 |
| Andy Phillips | 9999‑0 | $2,500 | $4,180 | Bears: $2,500 |
| James Turner | 9999‑0 | $2,500 | $2,733 | Lions: $2,500 |
| Clayton Hatfield | 9999‑0 | $2,000 | $2,967 | Colts: $2,000 |
| Nick Vogel | 9999‑0 | $2,000 | $2,817 | Ravens: $2,000 |
| Jeremiah Detmer | 9999‑0 | $1,500 | $2,923 | Bears: $1,500 |
| David Marvin | 9999‑0 | $1,000 | $1,576 | Falcons: $1,000 |